Welcome to Your New Favorite
Restaurant in New Castle, PA


Fresh ingredients, delicious food, warm atmosphere. What more can you ask for? At Four Pizzeria, we're here to serve you and yours with the most delicious Italian and American classics New Castle has to offer. We only use the freshest ingredients to craft our homemade dishes, ensuring your taste buds' delight. From delectable antipasti items to beautifully crafted entrees, at Four Pizzeria we make sure you and your stomach are well taken care off.


Now that we've got your mouth watering, visit our menu page to see our full selection of homemade meals. Don't forget to check out our beer and wine menu as well. We have an extensive selection to choose from to enjoy in our restaurant, or to go.


Four Pizzeria welcomes you to experience everything we have to offer. Bring your friends and family and let us cook for you tonight. For more information on our restaurant, our menu, or any other inquiries you may have, feel free to give us a call at (724) 658-3380. We look forward to feeding you.


Come In & Stay a While

At Four, you're family. That is why we have designed our restaurant for you and yours to fully enjoy. Grab a seat at the bar and watch the game with an ice cold beer. Or you can take a table by our indoor fire pit for a cozier backdrop. Our food is made perfect by our warm, inviting dining space made for you and your friends and family to eat, drink and be happy.

Private Events

If you're hosting a larger party, let us accommodate you. Take the stress out of prepping and planning and leave the heavy lifting to us. We have the food, the space, and the dedicated wait staff. Just bring yourself, your party, and empty stomachs. We're happy to host your graduation parties, wedding rehearsal dinners, and more. Just give us a call at (724) 658-3380 and we'll take care of the rest.

Our Reviews

  • I have eaten here 3 times. Good food, homemade salad dressings, great prices. I recognize others have had customer service issues I have not at all. A favorite when in New Castle


    — Frank B.

    Button

  • Slide title

    This was my first time at Four Pizzeria. I had the Caprese salad and the Chicken & Shrimp Romano. The Caprese salad was a bit different that I am used to, but it was delicious. The same can be said about my entree. The chicken was cooked perfectly. The portions are quite large and the prices were reasonable. My server was attentive and prompt. I will definitely be back when I visit New Castle.


    — Terri G

    Button

  • Slide title

    This is one of the best having been to the old location several times before the move north. Friendly staff and owners. Our most recent visit proved proved that beyond just good it was outstanding!! Derek the youngest chef in the kitchen prepared the chicken Vincenzo with flare and grace. A full bar awaits those so inclined and a side entrance allows takeout and beer to go. If you are a local, stop by for a delicious wonderful experience from start to finish. A must for of out of towners too. You will not regret.


    — Bruce C.

    Button

  • Slide title

    I was here for the first time yesterday and it was a great dining experience. Our hostess Breezy was very nice and Patrick our waiter was the best; hands down. Though having bread and oil is never a bad thing to have for your guests as they wait for their food. You can tell how nice a restaurant is by the longevity of their staff. They must be doing well, because both people I spoke with at random times have been there for six years. Great atmosphere....great food....great people.


    — Larry T.

    Button

  • Slide title

    Our lunch was out of this world as well as dessert! Pizza Frittata and Cheesecake were to die for! Our server was superb and super friendly! Look forward to our next visit. One of my favoriste plalces to go when we are in the area!!!


    — Tabitha S.

    Button

Come & Eat With Us

At Four Pizzeria, we make sure that you are taken care of. With our menu of delicious, homemade dishes and our extensive wine and beer selection, you'll be happy you chose us. Come in and see us today!

Share by: